Sorry to hear that you had a Trophy lemon. So far, this 11 year old with 28k miles on it has been great. My other bike is 2011 Sprint GT. The Trophy has superior wind protection, and has been fun to ride longer distances. I have had some issues with the Sprint gearbox resisting upshifts, although that seems to be more so early in the ride. The Sprint is much more agile in the corners, though.
I do appreciate the quiet motors on both of these, although I understand the benefits of a loud engine on the awareness of drivers around you. Personal choices, I guess. I rarely ride in cities or heavy traffic and limit my miles on interstates, reducing the times when a loud engine helps others be aware of you.
I hope that you've been happy with your HD! Which one do you have?